Welcome to BIPA
No more talk. Its time for action!
That was the key message from members of the Barbados Investors and Policyholders Alliance at their most recent meeting at the Anne Johnson Auditorium. The alliance has now instructed its Attorney-at-Law, Tariq Khan, to “invoke pre-action protocols” against the directors of CLICO, the Office of the Supervisor of Insurance and others.
This is the first step in the process of establishing who ought to be subject to legal action as a result of the collapse of the insurance company which has left many of the 25,000 Barbadian CLICO policyholders and their families in a state of desperation and destitution.
“Many of our members wanted to do this from the start,” says BIPA Chairperson June Fowler, “but we fully expected the Judicial Manager to initiate action of this kind a long time ago, and kept recommending to our members that we would explore all other avenues of persuasion and inclusion before considering and initiating legal action such as this.”
She continued: “But after over a year of trying to bring pressure via the media for an early solution; putting up with a litany of unfulfilled promises, empty reassurances, the silent treatment from Government, as well as resistance to BIPA’s application to participate in the judicial management process as a legitimate intervener, the alliance is unable to contain its frustration any longer and has decided enough is enough!”
“A giant slap in the face!” That is how June Fowler, Chairperson of the Barbados Investors and Policyholders Alliance (BIPA), describes the disturbing absence in the Budget of any significant disclosure signalling further movement towards the promised June 2012 resolution to the CLICO debacle. “At least we know the Minister of Finance reads the Nation and is into recycling,” says Fowler, “because every word he spoke, we had all already read in a series of articles published in its pages months ago, together with proposals put forward in detail last year by the Judicial Manager.”
Already unimpressed by some of the ‘Options’ previously put forward by the Judicial Managers; frustrated by Government’s continued silence on official Reports; perturbed by the unconscionable lack of communication with policyholders, and troubled by the refusal to keep this matter of national importance on the Government’s ‘front burner’, BIPA deplores the fact that yet another promise to 35,000 Barbadians has been broken by the Government, and that the 10,000 BAICO policyholders didn’t even get a mention in the Budget speech.
The Alliance is also baffled by the Minister of Finance’s apparent failure to recognise the ripple effects Government’s inertia on the CLICO and BAICO fiascos is having on the local economy he claims so keen to boost. It is not just the victims and their families who are suffering, but also local businesses which policyholders are no longer able to patronise. “Imagine the difference to the state of the economy if the $854 million owed to policyholders was back in their hands and circulating locally,” points out June Fowler.
BIPA is adding this latest betrayal to the litany of previous unfulfilled promises and empty re-assurances, and laments the announcement of more meetings at which proposals are only “expected to be presented and discussed”. In particular, the Alliance is horrified at the sudden inclusion of the statement by the Minister of Finance that “if this effort at a resolution fails, the likelihood will be of devastating consequences for thousands of policyholders.”
Recoiling from this comment, June Fowler asks, “Are these the utterances of a Government that has given ‘a solemn promise’ or an undertaking to ‘stand by’ its words, let alone a Government that claims to humble itself and admit that they dropped the ball in many respects?” she adds. “Have they forgotten already that the wanton mismanagement of policyholders’ funds was allowed to happen and persist on their watch due to inadequate financial legislation and regulation, the negligence of regulatory bodies, and their continued procrastination and prevarication, instead of dealing with the problem head on from the start?”
Despite Government’s lack of commitment to their promise to find an expeditious and favourable resolution to this national scandal, BIPA remains committed to pursuing a fully satisfactory outcome for CLICO and BAICO policyholders using all available avenues and remedies, and looks forward to the continuing support of policyholders and stakeholders.
Response to Letter to the Editor in Nation newspaper of April 27th, from Mary Antione of St. Lucia, suggesting BIPA should make specific suggestions about the action to be taken on the CLICO debacle, and do ‘more real work’ instead of just ‘dropping hints’. Of course we had to respond firmly to that!
By – JUNE FOWLER, Barbados Investors & Policyholders Alliance Inc.
The Barbados Investors & Policyholders Alliance (BIPA) would like to thank Mary Antoine of St Lucia for her constructive comments and suggestions in the DAILY Nation of April 26, which have been noted.
We would also like to reassure Ms Antoine that, far from dropping “hints”, BIPA is already working through the courts to achieve one of a number of its objectives on behalf of its policyholding members, and that a great deal of other “real work” is going on behind the scenes, as well as in the public domain.
BIPA continues to monitor closely the work being done by the judicial manager. Given the millions of dollars in fees already paid and the granting by the court of what amounts to a “blank cheque” for its continuing costs, BIPA fully anticipates and expects the judicial manager to present an all-encompassing resolution for the 25 000 Barbadians and thousands more Eastern Caribbean people who are disastrously affected by this debacle.
The alliance also expects the timely commencement of legal proceedings against any and all of CLICO’s officers and directors who are found to have broken the laws of the land and/or failed to perform their fiduciary duties.
In the meantime, BIPA eagerly awaits the announcement of details of the proposals by the Barbados Government presenting a solution to the CLICO situation, which has been promised by the Minister of Finance to be delivered in the next eight weeks.
If necessary, BIPA will challenge or counter the proposals on behalf of its members, but for the time being, does not seek to make specific proposals of its own, and trusts that the final proposals made resulting from the various judicial manager’s reports will be inclusive of and satisfactory to all policyholders.